The  Blog

A collection of musings for the modern masculine...

5 Lessons from a Recovering 'Nice Guy': How to Stop Sacrificing Yourself and Start Living Authentically

#betamale #datingadvice #healthymasculinity #incel #masculine #masculinityisnottoxic #niceguy #nofap #nomoremrniceguy codependency Jan 16, 2023

 Are you a "nice guy" who always finishes last? You're not alone.

Have you ever found yourself bending over backward to please others, only to feel overlooked or taken for granted? This phenomenon is a common trap that many fall into in their personal and professional lives. There is currently an epidemic in modern culture. This epidemic has impacted countless men, from all cultures and walks of life. Many of these men are living a false life, pretending to be something they are not. These men live in a state of perpetual dissatisfaction, which they are perplexed by because in their minds they are doing all the "right" things. Author Dr. Robert Glover labels the phenomenon of post-modern men, who live in a perpetual state of people-pleasing and considerable compromise, "nice-guy syndrome."

As a culture, we tend to conflate niceness with positivity and have an assumption that there is an inherent goodness motivating the behaviors in men that would consider themselves to be nice guys. What we tend to see in a lot of modern men are patterns of relating that will undermine and erode the health of a relationship over time, generally breeding a lack of safety and considerable resentments for all parties.

The characteristics of men that tend to fall into the realm of the nice guy persona generally include an internalized sense of not feeling worthy of love or acceptance. This usually includes an identity that is shame-based at its core. When we are motivated by a sense of unworthiness, we tend to be willing to do anything to be liked. Generally, nice guys outsource their validation. They believe that if they avoid conflict and try to read the room and others' expectations of them, and then adapt accordingly to meet everyone else's needs and desires before their own, they will be liked. On the contrary, nice guys are often not respected because they don't respect themselves. They also breed a climate of distrust within the relationship culture because they generally are not upfront about their needs and expectations.

The challenge for nice guys is this; most of these behaviors have been practiced for a lifetime and have been playing out under the radar for so long, it can be hard to pinpoint. One of the telltale indicators of a nice guy's manipulative tactics is the giving to get mechanism. Or what Dr. Glover would call "covert contracts". A nice guy strategy to get validation often involves doing for others. While generally we would consider this a positive thing, in this case, it's not. For a nice guy when he gives to you, he expects a return on his investment. The deceitful thing about it is, he doesn't tell you what he expects from you. He just kind of secretly holds it over your head. This can be as seemingly innocent as just wanting to be liked or validated. But it can go as far as buying a woman dinner and then flowers, and then a vacation, and getting pissed at her when she doesn't want to be sexual with you. The covert contract of seeking validation over time can lead a nice guy to angry outbursts and emotional manipulation to get what they were seeking. If you find yourself in a relationship resenting the other person because they didn't give you something you never asked for, you might want to diagnose yourself with nice guy syndrome.

Another diagnostic tool to determine if you have nice guy syndrome is asking yourself in any given situation what it is that you truly want or need. Nice guys like to pretend they don't have needs, or they are unimportant. In reality, they suppress these parts of themselves because they feel undeserving. Nice guys suck at setting boundaries because they are generally out of touch with themselves, causing them to compromise their own boundaries or let their boundaries be crossed all the time.

Nice guys at their core are not bad people but underneath the idea that their niceness makes them good is a feeling that they are bad and need to compensate for their inherent badness. Nice guys have inherited the false belief they are somehow fundamentally flawed. That they are not enough as they are. This causes them to use adaptive strategies, like compromising and being accommodating, to minimize the potential to be rejected, not liked, or not loved. They will lie or tell half-truths (while convincing themselves they are being honest), people-please, avoid conflict, and generally play safe and small, shying away from any risk that would tarnish what they believe is their stainless reputation.

As a recovering "nice guy" myself I struggled a lot in relationships because I was afraid of abandonment. I hid my true feelings and pretended like I didn't have needs or desires. I spiritually bypassed the very human and vulnerable parts of me that I was afraid to expose because I was so afraid of being judged by others.

I unconsciously tried to manipulate my partners by doing things for them to be seen as a good man, while secretly resenting them for not reciprocating. This would result in passive-aggressive attacks from me, pouting and shutting down, when I felt neglected. It wasn't until I was in a relationship with a woman who was willing to call me out on my bullshit and hold me accountable for my actions that I was able to see my patterns for what they were. It was humbling and painful to see the impact that my nice guy behaviors had on my relationships. I realized that my fear of abandonment was causing me to abandon myself. It was only when I was willing to confront the uncomfortable truth about myself that I was able to begin the journey of healing and transformation.

Women are often attracted to the "bad boy" because, in a way, they know what they are getting from these men. They are not living to please her; they are living on their own terms. This can be more trustworthy for a woman than the manipulative games that a "nice guy" might play. Of course, the "bad boy" is not an emotionally mature version of a man either.

I've learned after many years of intentional inner work that it is possible to overcome nice guy syndrome and start living authentically.

Here are five lessons that I've learned in my recovery from being a nice guy that have helped me along with many of my clients:

  1. Give only if it's given freely: Be aware of where you have hidden strings attached to your actions and anywhere you are not forthcoming with your motives for reciprocation. Be honest with yourself and others about your true intentions and feelings.

  2. Tell the whole truth: Not sharing the whole truth is a nice guy's way of avoiding the possibility of conflict. When we avoid conflict, we create a battle within. Be honest with yourself and others about your true intentions and feelings. A man who can't stand with some spine in his own truth stands for nothing.

  3. Pause before saying "yes" to anything: That pause is a place of power. It gives you room to get clear on what you can stand behind and follow through on. It also gives you the space to feel into if it’s an authentic YES or if it's a people-pleasing yes.

  4. Set boundaries around the things that are important to you: Nice guys are great at neglecting themselves. Stop apologizing for having needs or acting like you don't have them. Stop waiting for permission to value yourself. Doing that actually makes you appear more "needy." Get clear on the conditions you need in your life and relationships to embody the best version of yourself and uphold the structures that enable that.

  5. Being “nice” does not entitle you to anyone's time, attention, or affection: When you honor the boundaries, autonomy, and free will of others, you create an atmosphere of respect and trust around you, which is admirable and naturally makes people want to do good on you. When you quietly manipulate others with your words or actions and pout when things don’t go your way, you create an atmosphere of distrust and revulsion.

The paradigm of the "nice guy" is an epidemic among modern men. It is a behavioral mechanism where a man withholds his truth for fear of disappointing others. This kind of habit is on autopilot for many men because this way of relating was a survival or coping strategy that was adopted from a young age.

If you learned that you needed to compromise some part of yourself to get your needs for love, care, or attention met, then it's likely that in your adult relationships you may have a hidden belief that says if you are completely honest with this person, then they might leave or not like you. Living within that frame of fundamental dishonesty with yourself and the world breeds a climate of distrust around you. The world can sense a man's lack of authenticity and withholding, particularly women. If you want to be trustable, practice being honest, especially when you're afraid to do so.

The deeper truth is, you are short-changing the world by hiding your vulnerabilities and your idiosyncrasies because standing beside those things is also your magnificence. You will never be enough if your aim is enoughness. As Carl Jung, the godfather of modern-day psychology, stated so simply: "I'd rather be whole than good."

True freedom does not come from having more money or more options with women; it comes from your capacity to risk sharing your authentic self and your deepest truth. Yes, there is a possibility of losing that job opportunity, that date, or even a significant other if you honor yourself. But if these things are not really aligned with who you are, ultimately they will make you miserable in the end. It's time to stop sacrificing yourself for the sake of being "nice" and start owning your experience.

The opposite of a nice guy is an integrated man. He is a man of integrity because he knows his values and his needs and takes responsibility for creating his life in alignment with them. He has developed enough respect and love for all parts of himself, both his shadows and his light, that he's able to act authentically in his truth and in his power.

If hearing what a "nice guy" is feels like a punch in the gut for you because it speaks to your experience or character, there is hope. The men that break free from this pattern do the inner work on themselves, which over time manifests itself as confidence, self-respect, and healthier relationships.

The key to overcoming nice guy syndrome is about developing a quality of backbone. If you think about a man with a strong backbone, you might picture a man standing up for what he believes in. There's a quality of unshakeability and being an uncompromising stand for what his non-negotiable terms for life and relationships are.

A man that lives a life of profound compromise struggles to set boundaries and ask for what he needs in a relationship tends to live in some kind of perpetual state of anxiety. When you live in a constant dread of how people perceive you, you will not be able to make the pivot into authenticity without the right tools. If you are without a constant threat response in your body, you need to learn how to regulate your own nervous system.

Breath is the gateway to conscious nervous system management. Breath gives you three primary functions beyond just providing you with oxygen. One is awareness. Because breath is so automated, it's one of the first things we become unconscious of. Simply noticing your breathing pattern allows you to come into a state of awareness. Breath is also the primary mechanism for feeling our feelings. We often hold our breath when we don't want to feel something. Nice guys are out of touch with their wants and needs because they are emotionally constipated. Breath helps you to complete the feeling cycle. And lastly, breath taps into the physiology of the nervous system on a primal level. Working with your breath consciously cultivates the agency you need to literally shift your nervous system from a fight, flight, freeze response to one of relaxed composure.

Beyond the concepts presented in overcoming nice guy syndrome, if your body-mind is not on board for the new agenda, it will be hard to make the necessary changes in how you relate to the world.

That's why I believe so strongly in the power of somatic practices. They go beyond the mind and deep into our physiology, accessing the limbic parts of our nervous system, which were in development at the time many of these relational patterns emerged, our early childhood.


Make sure to sign up for my free breathwork download here, to start to master your mind and your emotions. 

Have you experienced 'nice guy' syndrome? Share your story in the comments below.